Equality watchdog proposes a legal right for UK workers to know colleagues’ pay

Colleagues in a meeting around an office table

Would you ask your colleague what they earn? Most people in Britain still could not, and could lose standing by trying. The country’s equality watchdog has now proposed changing that, and we should say up front that this is a recommendation rather than law, and that reasonable people disagree about how far it should go.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission wants workers to have a legal right to know their colleagues’ pay where there is a suspicion of discrimination. As the BBC puts it, bosses should be required to respond to questionnaires about colleagues’ pay. The Telegraph reports the same proposals, which would also ban employers from asking job applicants what they earned in a previous role. The Guardian notes the EHRC frames this chiefly as protection against pay discrimination, particularly against women.

The gap the watchdog is pointing at is technical but real. Under the Equality Act, a claimant needs a comparator, someone doing equal work whose pay differs. But the pay information usually sits with the employer, and an employee has no legal mechanism to demand it. So claims often stall before they start. A right to ask, with a duty to answer, moves the burden to where the data actually is.

Our own reading of the proposals is limited by what has been published so far. The EHRC has set out the direction, but the exact mechanics, which employers are covered and how quickly they must respond, are not final, and the government has taken no decision. A consultation on equal pay and pay discrimination run by the government closed only yesterday, the 27 October, and ministers will want to see that response before acting.

Employers’ concerns deserve a fair hearing too. Pay transparency inside a firm can create resentment where roles only look similar, and small businesses will carry the admin of formal questionnaires. The counter, favoured by the watchdog, is that secrecy has never protected good-faith employers; it mostly protects the ones with something to hide. Countries with published pay bands, like Norway’s disclosure regime, have not collapsed under the awkward conversations.

It may not be settled before the next election, and nobody should pretend to know how the government will land on it. What is already clear is that the burden of the proposal would fall on the employer, not the individual. A worker would be able to ask through a formal questionnaire process without having to go and confront a colleague over the works canteen table. The practical machinery of it, who answers and within how many days, is the part to read carefully in any response the Treasury publishes, because that is where rights like this either work or quietly do not.

Secret Link